Friday, April 01, 2005

Punjabeefied

There is anti-Punjab strike in Pakistan. When do we do this in India?


Punjabis have infiltrated the Indian fabric in every way, the salwar kameez, the films, the food, the music (oh! The music!). I even make effort to understand what Rabbi rambles. The problem is, the guys are fun-loving, boisterous, loaded and know how to live it up. Rest of the Indias are comparitively meek, submissive and boring. And poor. In many cases, the Punjabification cannot be wished away. The Salwar Kameez is the most convenient wear for Indian woman. Rest of us, can learn from the Punju jest for life. But the Punjabi excess in films has crossed the limits of endurance. All the imp Bollywood families unfortunately are Punjabis, so for them its first nature to douse the whole film in Punjabi slush (sargon ka saag, punjabi spouting unrelative, the irritating bhangra number, loud humour).


In fact, my biggest grouse, is the disservice Punjabi guys are doing to Indian music. The bhangra thing is getting on my nerves. The Punjabi diaspora with a sorry mish-mash of broken Punjabi and street English are creating unprecedented cacophony. Rabbi is a the only saving grace.


Traditionally, Urdu shayars have had a stronghold in song writing department. So, Sanskrit based Hindi never came in style. And now Punjabi lingo has encroached a big way. Soniya, Mahiya, Peinda, Lashkara, ... Think how unhappy that is going to make the cows of UP, that words like prem, premi/premika, hriday, sharir(!), lagaav, praan, prannath, satya, gunh (quality), shabd, are eschewed completely.

So lets all eschew Punjabi. Bole So nihaal

5 comments:

Anonymous said...

Well written.

But its mainly their culture that gives
them more freedom and plus they also put
things well and in an entertaining way.
And there are many other plus points on
their side.

AM

P.S. I just hope that strike doesnt
start big riots in Pak.

Abhi T said...

True, but its their almost complete dominance on Indian Popular culture that has me slightly worried. Its not that they make terribly good stuff. It's just that they have muscle power. Which I am sure doesnt allow lot of non-Punjabi and possibly more creative stuff to get in to mainstream. This is certainly not by design (to keep non Panju people out), but by a lack of understanding and appreciation of other cultures.

Sony said...

This is an interesting discussion. I am British of Panjabi origin. I can understand your point of view. However having panjabi people in the media does have it's bad points aswell.

The stereotyping of panjabi people can be abit nauseating at times. For example most films and music videos show the 'Sikh' man to be the butt of all jokes.

I have to admit that some of the 'music' coming out of Panjab or of Panjabi origin is very poor.

That's why when I heard Rabbi Shergils' album I thought he was speaking in another language because my ears have been acustomed to hearing 'Balle Balle' and 'Shaava Shaava' about fifty times in one song.

Be sure that I think you have a valid point. I hope things change and the media becomes less "Panjabi - Hindu" centric

Thanks for a thought provoking blog

Anonymous said...

Punjabi culture is not so rampant/popular in southern India. And the music, surely, isn't that good - the sound & the videos have the same feel. I don't understand how you can generalise like this?!!!

Abhi T said...

Punjabi culture is mainstream in India. If you go to Chennai discs, you may hear the balle balle and chak di patte more often than the vice versa (Tamil music heard elsewhere). Women in Tamil Nadu wear Salwar Kurta don't they, not padavai.
If POPO (people of punjabi origin dominate Hindi media (films, TV and entertainment), then that calls for a generalization.
You are talking of exceptions.